“A gay individual cannot be a Christian.” It’s a sentence author Robert D. Holmes says he has heard his entire life. In his memoir, Gay and a Disciple of the Lord Jesus Christ, he sets out to explain why he believes that statement gets something fundamental wrong.
Holmes draws a distinction that runs through the entire book: the difference between orientation and lifestyle. Orientation, he writes, is the attraction a person experiences — something discovered, not chosen. Lifestyle is the pattern of choices a person makes in response to that attraction. For Holmes, conflating the two is where the conversation breaks down, both inside and outside the church.
It’s a distinction he didn’t arrive at easily. Holmes became a Christian as a young child and felt called into ministry while still in college — a calling he pursued for the next forty years across children’s, youth, music, and Hispanic ministries in the U.S. and Honduras. His relationship with God, in other words, came first. His understanding of his own orientation came later, and it arrived as a source of confusion rather than clarity. For years, he prayed for it to simply disappear, and when it didn’t, he wondered — as many in his position have — whether something was wrong with him.
What makes Gay and a Disciple of the Lord Jesus Christ distinct isn’t that it resolves that tension neatly. It doesn’t. Holmes is candid that his own choices, at various points, were “questionable” by the standards he held for himself. He doesn’t present his life as a model to be copied. What he offers instead is something more honest: a portrait of a man who never stopped believing that his faith and his orientation both belonged to him, even when he couldn’t fully reconcile the two.
That honesty is likely to be uncomfortable for some readers, on both ends of the conversation. Holmes doesn’t ask readers to abandon their theology, and he doesn’t abandon his own. What he asks is smaller and, in some ways, harder: to consider that a person can be genuinely, imperfectly devoted to Christ while still working out questions that don’t have tidy answers. “His grace is greater than human judgment,” Holmes writes — not as a conclusion, but as the thread that holds his whole story together.
For readers who have long assumed the question “can you be gay and Christian” has an obvious answer — in either direction — Holmes’s memoir doesn’t offer a debate. It offers a life. And it invites readers to sit with the discomfort of a story that refuses to be simplified.