Few love stories begin the way Robert and Neyda Holmes’s did. In Gay and a Disciple of the Lord Jesus Christ, Holmes writes with striking candor about marrying his wife while she was already aware of his same-sex attraction — and about the forty-three years, one adopted son, and complicated, evolving partnership that followed.
It would be easy to tell this story as either a cautionary tale or a triumphant one. Holmes does neither. He describes real loneliness — his own, and hers. He writes about the years they considered separation and divorce, wanting to give Neyda “another opportunity for her future,” and about her choice, each time, to stay. He doesn’t romanticize that choice or explain it away. He simply presents it as true, and as one of the central mysteries of his life: why the person who understood the hardest thing about him chose, again and again, to remain.
What emerges is not a portrait of a perfect marriage, but of a persistent one — two people, both trying to build a life around their shared faith, working with a set of circumstances neither had fully anticipated. Holmes writes about the practical seasons of that marriage alongside the emotional ones: teaching jobs, a move to San Diego, a period of living apart, a reconciliation, and the adoption of their son, Derick. The marriage isn’t the backdrop to his story. It’s one of its central threads, running alongside — and often intersecting with — his ministry work and his ongoing relationship with his own identity.
Readers looking for a tidy explanation of how a marriage like this “works” won’t find one here, and that seems intentional. Holmes doesn’t offer his marriage as a formula. He offers it as a record — of difficulty acknowledged rather than hidden, of two people who kept choosing each other inside circumstances that gave them every reason not to, and of a partnership that, whatever else it was, was never dishonest about what it was.
For readers navigating their own complicated relationships — whether around identity, faith, or simply the gap between what a marriage looks like from the outside and what it feels like from within — the story of Robert and Neyda offers something rarer than advice: an honest look at what forty-three years of staying can actually involve.