Most memoirs about a hidden struggle focus on the years before the truth came out. Gay and a Disciple of the Lord Jesus Christ is unusual because so much of Robert D. Holmes’s story takes place during — years of active, visible ministry work, carried out while he held a private truth he feared could end it all.
Holmes’s ministry résumé is not a footnote to his story; it’s the backbone of it. Children’s ministry. Youth ministry. Music ministry. Hispanic ministry, conducted largely in Spanish across churches in the U.S. and Central America. For four decades, much of it bi-vocational — meaning he held full-time secular work alongside his church commitments — Holmes was, by any outward measure, exactly the kind of steady, dedicated servant a congregation hopes for.
What the pews didn’t see was the internal negotiation running underneath all of it. Holmes writes about “crashing” a party as a young youth minister trying to reach troubled teens, about summer ministries in Ohio, Kansas, and the Dominican Republic, about building a Hispanic praise team from nothing in Missouri. Threaded through those very ordinary ministry milestones is a private question he carried the entire time: what would happen to all of it if people knew the truth about his orientation?
It’s a tension many readers may not associate with church work — the idea that someone can be fully present, fully effective, and fully sincere in ministry while also managing a fear that has nothing to do with their competence or their calling. Holmes doesn’t frame this as hypocrisy. He frames it as survival, and eventually, as a slow, imperfect walk toward honesty — first with his brother, later with his parents, and throughout, with God.
What’s striking is how ordinary the ministry chapters feel next to how extraordinary the underlying story is. Holmes writes about vacation Bible schools and praise teams with the same plainspoken detail he uses to describe the fear of being found out. That contrast is, in its own way, the point: a hidden struggle doesn’t always look dramatic from the outside. Sometimes it looks like forty years of faithful service, carried by someone quietly wondering if that service would survive the truth.
For anyone who has ever kept a part of themselves separate from their public role — in ministry or anywhere else — Holmes’s account of holding both at once, for decades, offers a rare and specific kind of company.